• June 19, 2025

Making Strategic Technology Investments in Times of Austerity

Rocks balanced on other rocks. Text reads: "Making Strategic Technology Investments in Times of Austerity"

Making Strategic Technology Investments in Times of Austerity

Making Strategic Technology Investments in Times of Austerity 1024 536 Vantage Technology Consulting Group

Rocks balanced on other rocks. Text reads: "Making Strategic Technology Investments in Times of Austerity"

Building the Case in Higher Education

As the federal government reduces funding for a broad array of higher education programs and grants, universities are slashing budgets, laying off staff, halting travel, enacting hiring freezes, and even suspending admissions. In this climate, IT leaders must make difficult decisions about where to allocate limited resources, ensuring that technology investments support institutional priorities while maintaining operational resilience.

Effectively making the case for IT funding requires a nuanced, strategic approach that goes beyond technical justifications and aligns with broader institutional objectives. Old models for securing funding for IT priorities are less and less likely to work in this environment. Here’s what IT leaders need to know about making the case for strategic investments in times of austerity.

A Framework for Prioritization

To help navigate budget constraints, we find it useful to categorize technology investments into four key tiers as you evaluate your options:

  • Focused Investment: Systems that are mission-critical or essential to maintaining security and compliance.
  • Strategic Investment for Innovation: Focused investments around technologies to enable innovation in the institutional mission. Typically made in close consultation with institutional leadership related to institutional innovation initiatives or strategic planning priorities.
  • Minimum Acceptable Levels: Technologies where spending can be optimized through strategic deferral, leveraging alternative solutions, or reducing service levels while maintaining core functionality.
  • Discontinuation: Non-essential technologies or services where some level of degradation or discontinuation is an acceptable trade-off.

Determining which investments fall into which category is easier said than done. Different stakeholders and leaders are likely to disagree about which technology investments are essential, and which are nice-to-haves; even which things can be discontinued.

Making the Most of Limited Resources

People: Staff time is finite. How can you help your team prioritize their time?

Money: Are your investments helping advance your strategic mission and goals?

Political Capital: What battles are worth fighting, and how are you building trust?

While you should solicit input from a broad swath of stakeholders—from end users to executive decision-makers—many university administrators are going to look to IT leadership to make informed recommendations about where to focus limited resources . You’ll need to summon your strongest communication skills to understand how services are and will be leveraged, bring fresh ideas for how technology can make the mission more successful (and where it gets in the way), and convey the right-sized investment required.

Addressing Risk with Transparency

Historically, IT organizations have often justified expenditures by emphasizing the most catastrophic failure risks. The risk in using this approach is that campus leaders have heard the same story many times and may start thinking of IT as “the boy who cried wolf.” That reputation can be hard to shake; and if it prevents IT from securing necessary resources, it can leave an institution vulnerable.

Though full system meltdowns are a serious threat, the more pervasive risk is often the gradual erosion of stability: a “death by a thousand cuts.” No IT department will intentionally allow the most devastating system failure to happen, so they cobble together all the duct tape and bailing twine they can muster to keep things running. Though chaos may reign behind the scenes, what the wider community sees is a system that appears to be working, albeit with a hiccup here or there.

The resulting aging infrastructure, overextended staff, and incremental service degradations may not trigger immediate alarms, but they insidiously undermine institutional effectiveness and create a brittle situation far more likely to shatter in unpredictable ways.

IT leaders need to draw back the curtain and adopt a more transparent approach to risk management when seeking funds for strategic IT investments. These leaders can help non-technical decision-makers distinguish between symptoms and root causes to help their institutions make informed choices about which risks are tolerable and which demand urgent attention.

By more accurately conveying the most likely risks an institution faces when it neglects its technology infrastructure, IT leaders can start rebuilding trust and demonstrating the potential institutional impact of investing (or not investing) in key technologies. Leaders should highlight not only the immediate consequences of funding reductions but also the cumulative effects such as staff burnout, operational inefficiencies, inability to innovate and support institutional change, and escalating long-term costs.

Again, taking a critical look at what tools you can afford to discontinue or allow some degradation in service capabilities will help you make the case for and build alignment around tools that warrant full investment. Coming to an agreement with institutional leaders on the level of risk you’re willing to take on will help you make these decisions.

Instilling a “Buy Once, Cry Once” Mentality

For investments that fall into the “focused investment” category, it may be tempting to spend minimally on a tool that will hopefully get your institution through discreet moments of financial hardship. However, the instinct to seek the least expensive option can be short-sighted. Investing in durable, well-supported technology solutions can prevent the cycle of repeated reinvestment in lower-quality alternatives.

Microwave with sign taped to it that reads "Out of Order"Many homeowners will know from experience that skimping on things like kitchen appliances is often more costly in the long run when they have to replace that appliance in short order with the one they knew was right from the beginning. IT leaders must help decision-makers understand the long-term implications of their decisions, demonstrating that short-term savings, especially when it comes to technology, can result in significantly higher costs down the line.

This does not mean always buying the most expensive solution. It means being intentional when evaluating options to make the purchase that fits the intended purpose with the right risk profile. In Vantage’s experience, once alternate vendors are considered, there are often considerable cost savings versus the conventional incumbent.

Similarly, scalable technology investments can provide strong value by supporting innovation without requiring major costs until the institution has a clearer long-term direction. Supported open-source solutions are often a compelling option in trying to balance the right tool with the right investment.

Guiding Leadership in Decision-Making

One of the greatest challenges IT leaders face in periods of budget constraints is that non-IT leadership often reduces funding without explicitly deciding what work should be eliminated. Lip service may be paid to the need to reduce workloads alongside decreasing investments in tools and platforms, but easing employee workloads rarely gets the same level of planning or attention.

IT leaders must take an active role in facilitating these discussions, making it clear that resource reductions necessitate operational trade-offs. A strong case for continued investment should not only highlight the financial request but also articulate how human resources will be allocated to support the investment, as well as where levels of support must be reduced or eliminated.

To win the support of non-IT leadership, IT leaders should come to budget discussions prepared with a list of what has already been deferred or eliminated. Demonstrating steps proactively taken toward cost avoidance can help justify cost necessity and build trust. This tactic can also help decision-makers see how essential services can continue to be supported even when staff support is shifted.

Helping leaders determine which investments can be discontinued is often the most difficult step. Many institutions are successful in deciding what to add but struggle to ever terminate a service.

– Kirk Kelly, Vice President

Elevating IT as a Strategic Partner

As higher education institutions grapple with financial constraints driven by federal funding cuts and nationwide enrollment declines, IT must be at the forefront of institutional resilience. IT leaders should position their departments as partners in the work to protect the institution while continuing to deliver for students, faculty, and staff. By framing technology investments within the context of mission alignment, security, and long-term sustainability, IT leaders can help their institutions navigate uncertainty in a responsible way.

As you evaluate options and make investments, IT must be able to convey to institutional leadership:

  • Transparency and pragmatism
  • That the proposed solution is the right balance of cost versus achievable value
  • The “why” in terms that resonate with each specific audience
  • How you’re creating a solid foundation to build upon

This post was co-authored by Vice President Kirk Kelly, who advises clients on strategic planning, IT and data governance, educational and classroom technologies, and initiatives that transform institutional academic and administrative capabilities; and Vice President Jon Young, who provides consulting related to information security, privacy, IT and data governance, policy development, risk management, compliance, disaster recovery and business continuity, network design and architecture, organizational transformation, and funding.

Need Help?

Our team of higher education experts is available to help you make strategic technology investments that prepare your organization for long-term success, even in difficult financial moments.